|
QUICK ANSWER
A cast super duplex replacement part is not automatically interchangeable with the wrought original. ASTM A995 (A890) grade 5A is the nearest cast equivalent of S32750 and grade 6A is the nearest equivalent of S32760, but "nearest" is not "identical".
Verify seven things before you accept it: (1) the grade match and heat chemistry, especially nitrogen and PREN; (2) minimum strength against the design; (3) solution annealing and an ASTM A923 intermetallic screen; (4) ferrite balance by point count; (5) internal soundness by radiography or ultrasonics; (6) every weld repair and its heat treatment; and (7) corrosion and sour-service evidence. Get the proof on a heat-traceable certificate and a written approval from the engineer who owns the design. |

This guide is for maintenance planners, procurement teams and owners' engineers who need a spare pump casing, impeller, valve body or fitting that was originally made from wrought super duplex (forged, bar or plate) and now has to be bought as a casting. It is written in plain language, and each section answers one question you can copy into a purchase specification.
|
Term |
What it means |
|
Wrought |
Metal that was rolled, forged or drawn into shape from a solid billet or ingot, such as bar, plate and forgings. |
|
Casting |
A part made by pouring molten metal into a mould. It is useful for complex shapes, but the metal cools unevenly. |
|
Replacement part |
A spare that must fit and perform like the original in an existing plant, usually without redesigning the equipment. |
|
UNS number |
A standard material ID. S-numbers (S32750) are wrought alloys. J-numbers (J93404) are cast alloys. |
|
PREN |
Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number: Cr + 3.3 × Mo + 16 × N. A higher number means better pitting resistance. Super duplex is usually 40 or higher. |
|
Solution annealing |
Heating the metal to a high temperature and cooling it fast to dissolve harmful phases and restore the right structure. |
|
Ferrite and austenite |
The two crystal structures in duplex steel. A balance near 50/50 gives the best strength and corrosion resistance. |
|
Intermetallic phase |
Hard, brittle compounds such as sigma phase that form if duplex steel cools too slowly. They reduce toughness and corrosion resistance. |
|
NDE |
Non-destructive examination: radiography (RT), ultrasonics (UT), penetrant (PT) and magnetic particle (MT) testing that look for defects without cutting the part. |
|
Weld repair |
Welding used by the foundry to fill defects such as porosity or shrinkage cavities in a casting. |
Can a Cast Super Duplex Part Replace a Wrought One?
Yes, but only after the buyer or owner's engineer approves it in writing against the original wrought specification. The grade name alone does not prove equivalence.
Cast and wrought parts of the "same" alloy start from the same idea: about 25% chromium, a high nitrogen level and a roughly 50/50 mix of ferrite and austenite. But they are made differently, and the process changes the result. Castings cool unevenly in a mould, can contain shrinkage or gas pores, and are often repaired by welding. Wrought products are worked and tested in simpler shapes. As Langley Alloys notes, the mechanical properties of wrought material are significantly better than cast, and defects in castings often show up only after machining.
That is why the safe question is not "Is it super duplex?" but "Does this casting meet every requirement that the original wrought part met, for this service?" The rest of this guide breaks that question into parts you can check.
Which Cast Grade Corresponds to Which Wrought Super Duplex Grade?
Cast grade 5A (UNS J93404) is the nearest equivalent of wrought S32750, and cast grade 6A (UNS J93380) is the nearest equivalent of wrought S32760.
ASTM A890 and A995 are the same casting specification, with A995 being the metric version. They cover six "A" grades, from lower-alloy duplex up to grade 6A. Only 5A and 6A are super duplex. Grade 4A (J92205) matches standard 2205 duplex, so it is not a super duplex substitute.
|
Wrought grade |
Typical wrought specifications |
Nearest cast grade |
Cast specifications |
What to check |
|
S32750 (2507, F53) |
A182 F53 forgings; A276/A479 bar; A240 plate; A790 pipe |
5A, J93404 (CE3MN) |
ASTM A890 / A995; ASME SA-995 |
Nitrogen range, strength minimum, ferrite and heat treatment. |
|
S32760 (Zeron 100 type, F55) |
A182 F55; bar; plate; A790 pipe |
6A, J93380 (CD3MWCuN) |
ASTM A890 / A995; ASME SA-995 |
Tungsten and copper content, yield strength minimum (450 MPa). |
Source: Langley Alloys; MetalTek; ProjectMaterials; ASTM A995 table as reproduced. Cast and wrought designations are "nearest equivalents", not identical.
How Do the Chemistry Limits Compare Between Wrought S32750 and Cast 5A?
Most elements match, but the cast grade allows a lower minimum nitrogen, so nitrogen and PREN must be checked on every heat.

Nitrogen is the key element in super duplex. It helps austenite form, adds strength and raises pitting resistance. In the limits compared below, wrought F53 requires 0.24–0.32% nitrogen, while a foundry's published typical range for cast 5A starts at 0.10%. A casting at the low end could meet the cast grade but fall short of the wrought part's pitting resistance. The A995 text reviewed also carries a PREN minimum of 40 in a footnote to its composition table, so ask the foundry to report the calculated PREN for each heat.
|
Element |
Wrought F53 (S32750), A182 |
Cast 5A (J93404), foundry-published limits |
|
Carbon (max) |
0.030% |
0.030% |
|
Chromium |
24.0–26.0% |
24–26% |
|
Nickel |
6.0–8.0% |
6.0–8.0% |
|
Molybdenum |
3.0–5.0% |
4–5% |
|
Nitrogen |
0.24–0.32% |
0.10–0.30% |
|
Manganese (max) |
1.20% |
1.50% |
|
Silicon (max) |
0.80% |
1.00% |
Source: A182 F53 limits as listed by suppliers; MetalTek typical composition for CE3MN (5A); ASTM A995 composition table as reproduced. Confirm all limits in the current standard.
For 6A, the extra tungsten (0.5–1.0%) and copper (0.5–1.0%) in the cast grade mirror the wrought S32760 recipe. When the original part was S32760, check that the casting's certificate lists both elements.
How Do the Minimum Mechanical Properties Compare?
The cast grades have lower minimum strength than their wrought equivalents: about 6% lower yield for 5A and about 18% lower for 6A in the tables reviewed.
Minimum values are what the design can rely on. If the original wrought part was sized using 550 MPa yield strength, a cast replacement with a 450 MPa minimum has less margin. Either the section must be thicker, the stress must be lower, or the designer must accept the lower value in writing.
|
Property (minimum) |
Wrought F53 (S32750) |
Cast 5A |
Wrought F55 (S32760) |
Cast 6A |
|
Tensile strength |
800 MPa (116 ksi) |
690 MPa (100 ksi) |
750 MPa (109 ksi) |
690 MPa (100 ksi) |
|
Yield strength (0.2% offset) |
550 MPa (80 ksi) |
515 MPa (75 ksi) |
550 MPa (80 ksi) |
450 MPa (65 ksi) |
|
Elongation |
15% |
18% |
25% |
25% |
|
Hardness limit |
310 HBW max |
Set by purchaser |
Not listed in A1049; set by purchaser |
Set by purchaser |
Source: A182 F53 and A1049 (F55) as listed by suppliers and reproduced; ASTM A995-98 (R03) Table 3 for cast values. Some secondary sources quote other 5A yield values (485–550 MPa), so confirm in the current edition. Wrought values shown for 2 in (50 mm) and smaller sections.
Cast elongation is not always lower. Grade 5A lists 18% against 15% for F53. That is why you should compare each property separately instead of assuming one is "better".
How Should Heat Treatment and Microstructure Be Verified?
Ask for the solution-anneal record and an ASTM A923 intermetallic screen on the casting itself, plus a ferrite point count by ASTM E562.
Super duplex gets its properties from solution annealing: heating high, then cooling fast. A casting is annealed as a finished shape, often with thick and thin sections side by side. Thick sections cool more slowly, and slow cooling is when brittle intermetallic phases appear. The standards set different temperatures for each product form, so do not assume the wrought heat treatment applies.
|
Product |
Solution-anneal requirement |
What to ask for |
|
Wrought F53 (A182) |
Solution treat and quench from at least 1025°C (1880°F), cooling below 260°C (500°F). |
Heat-treat chart and quench record. |
|
Cast 5A (A995) |
Heat to at least 1120°C (2050°F), furnace cool to no lower than 1045°C (1910°F), then quench in water or cool rapidly. |
Furnace chart showing both temperatures and the quench delay. |
|
Cast 6A (A995) |
Heat to at least 1100°C (2010°F), then quench in water or cool rapidly. |
Furnace chart and quench record. |
Source: ASTM A995-98 (R03) Table 1; A182 F53 as listed by suppliers. Temperatures are minimums. Check the current editions.
ASTM A923 covers cast grades as well. In the 2008 tables reviewed, Method A (sodium hydroxide etch) lists J93404, and Method B (Charpy impact) lists J93404 base metal at –46°C (–50°F) with a 54 J minimum. A U.S. Department of Energy study of cast duplex grades tested A923 methods on 4A, 5A and 6A castings, and found its micrographs for cast 4A could be applied to 5A. Ferrite is best measured by ASTM E562 point count. A890 supplementary requirement S31 allows the purchaser to call for it.
How Is Casting Soundness Verified Compared With Wrought Material?
Wrought parts are inspected for a few defect types, but castings need broader NDE because shrinkage, porosity and inclusions can sit inside the metal and show up only after machining.
|
Concern |
Wrought (forged, bar, plate) |
Cast (A890 / A995) |
What to request |
|
Internal voids, shrinkage, porosity |
Less likely to contain internal defects. |
More likely. Often found only after machining. |
RT or UT to an agreed acceptance class, before and after rough machining. |
|
Surface-breaking defects |
Checked on machined surfaces. |
Checked on all accessible surfaces. |
PT or MT after final machining. NORSOK M-630 requires this step, with acceptance per ASME VIII-1 Appendix 7. |
|
Slow-cooled sections |
Fewer thick-to-thin transitions. |
Heavy sections cool slower, so intermetallic risk is higher. |
ASTM A923 on the thickest section. |
|
Property scatter |
Test on the product or a representative sample. |
Test bars poured in blocks from the same heat (A890 S32). |
Ask whether coupons were attached to or cast with the part for heavy or critical items. |
|
Repairs |
Rare. |
Common and sometimes major. |
Repair map, procedure and heat-treatment record (next section). |
Engineers quoting ASME Section VIII Division 2 say it requires cast material to be examined by radiography or ultrasonics and by magnetic particle or penetrant testing. Whatever your code, write the NDE method, extent and acceptance standard into the purchase order. "Casting quality" is not a testable requirement by itself.
What Should Buyers Know About Weld Repairs on Super Duplex Castings?
Weld repair is normal in castings, so the buyer should require a repair map, a qualified procedure and a stated heat-treatment rule.

A890 permits repair by welding. The deposited weld metal may be similar to the casting or may be a suitably alloyed filler chosen for corrosion resistance and strength. Heat treatment after repair is covered by supplementary requirement S33. It must be listed in the purchase order to apply. As reproduced, S33 requires heat treatment after major repairs. A repair is major if the prepared cavity is deeper than 20% of the wall thickness or 1 in (25 mm), whichever is smaller, or if the cavity area is more than about 10 in² (65 cm²). All other repairs are minor and are not heat-treated unless the purchaser says so.
For super duplex, the safe approach is to decide in advance:
- Where repairs are allowed. Ban repairs in critical sealing faces or highly stressed areas if the design requires it.
- How repairs are recorded. Ask for a repair map showing location, depth and area of every repair.
- What heat treatment follows. State whether minor repairs are also heat-treated and tested. Aging treatments that raise strength are not suitable because they can cause embrittling phases in duplex.
- What is re-tested. NDE of the repaired area and, for major repairs, the same A923 and ferrite checks as the casting.
Do Corrosion and Sour-Service Approvals Carry Over From the Wrought Part?
Not automatically. Approvals are tied to the product form, heat treatment and hardness, so ask for evidence on the cast part.
A pump-industry specification summarised in Pumps & Systems advises A890 grade 5A for both of its duty grades (D-1 and D-2), because it is the only grade it considers acceptable to both NACE MR0103 and MR0175. It also keeps duplex ferrite between 35% and 65% by volume and prohibits aging heat treatments. That is one specification's rule, not a universal one, but it shows the kinds of limits an owner may apply to a cast part.
Hardness matters in sour service. Wrought F53 is limited to 310 HBW (about 32 HRC), and the cast grades have no equivalent limit in the tensile table reviewed, so the purchaser must set it. For pitting resistance, some owners add an ASTM G48 test on the casting. One super duplex casting presentation, for example, reports G48 results against a NORSOK weight-loss limit of 4 g/m². Use the test method and temperature required by your own specification.
Does the Design Allowable Stress Change for a Cast Part?
Yes. Pressure codes reduce the allowable stress of castings with a casting quality factor, and the lower minimum yield strength also affects the design.
ASME Section VIII Division 1 requires allowable stress values for castings to be multiplied by a casting quality factor given in paragraph UG-24. ASME B31.3 piping uses a similar casting quality factor, and its value depends on how much radiographic and surface examination was done. In plain terms, a casting that is inspected more can be rated closer to a wrought part. A casting that is inspected less carries a penalty. So the NDE you buy is not only a quality check but also a design input.
Before approving the replacement, ask the designer to confirm the part's pressure rating or load capacity using the cast grade's minimum properties and the casting quality factor that matches the NDE you ordered.
What Is the Full Checklist for Approving a Cast Replacement Against the Wrought Specification?
Use these 14 checks. Each compares what the wrought original required with what the casting must prove, and names the evidence to request.
|
# |
Check |
Compare against the wrought original |
Evidence to request |
|
1 |
Grade equivalence |
Original UNS (S32750 or S32760) mapped to cast 5A or 6A. |
Written approval from the design owner. |
|
2 |
Heat chemistry |
Original limits for Cr, Ni, Mo, N, Cu, W. |
Heat analysis on the certificate, including nitrogen. |
|
3 |
PREN |
PREN of 40 or higher for super duplex. |
Calculated PREN for each heat. |
|
4 |
Strength |
Wrought minimum yield (550 MPa) against cast minimum (515 or 450 MPa). |
Tensile report for the heat; design check using cast minimums. |
|
5 |
Hardness |
Wrought limit (310 HBW max). |
Hardness reading on the finished part. |
|
6 |
Impact toughness |
Charpy requirement at the design temperature. |
Charpy report. A923 Method B lists J93404 at –46°C, 54 J. |
|
7 |
Heat treatment |
Solution anneal and quench for the grade. |
Furnace chart with temperatures and quench delay. |
|
8 |
Ferrite |
Typical 40–60% in wrought datasheets; your specified range. |
ASTM E562 point count on the casting. |
|
9 |
Intermetallic phase |
ASTM A923 for the original product. |
A923 Method A plus B or C on the casting. |
|
10 |
Pitting resistance |
Owner's G48 or NORSOK requirement, if any. |
G48 report at the agreed temperature. |
|
11 |
Soundness |
UT or RT of the original forging, if required. |
RT or UT, plus PT or MT after final machining. |
|
12 |
Weld repairs |
None or minimal on wrought parts. |
Repair map, procedure, heat-treatment record (S33). |
|
13 |
Design allowable |
Wrought stress values from the design code. |
Casting quality factor and stress calculation. |
|
14 |
Traceability |
Heat number and certificate on the original. |
Heat and casting number marking; EN 10204 3.1 or 3.2 certificate. |
When Should You Choose Cast and When Should You Stay With Wrought?
Choose cast for complex shapes and longer production runs, and stay with wrought bar, plate or forgings for one-off, highly stressed or critical parts.
|
Dimension |
Wrought (bar, plate, forging) |
Cast (A890 / A995) |
EETA view |
|
Strength |
Higher minimum yield and tensile strength. |
Lower minimums (5A and 6A). |
Check the design margin. |
|
Internal defects |
Much less likely to contain them. |
Can sit inside and appear after machining. |
Require NDE for cast. |
|
Complex shapes |
Needs heavy machining from solid. |
Efficient for impellers and valve bodies. |
Cast favoured. |
|
Cost and volume |
No pattern cost. Suits one-offs. |
Can cut cost on larger parts and longer runs. |
Depends on quantity. |
|
Risk of rejection |
Lower. Machining from solid bar reduces rejection risk. |
Higher until NDE and repairs are cleared. |
Wrought for urgent spares. |
|
Paperwork |
Simpler test set. |
Heavier: repair map, NDE, A923, ferrite. |
Budget for documents. |
What Can JN Alloy Supply or Verify for Super Duplex Replacement Parts?
JN Alloy supplies wrought super duplex product forms and lists in-house testing equipment, so it can support machined-from-wrought alternatives and material verification. Its website does not list castings, so confirm cast availability first.

According to its website, JN Alloy (Jinie Technology (Jiangsu) Co., Ltd.) lists super duplex steel among its alloy categories, with seamless pipes, plates and sheets, nickel alloy machined parts, oil and gas alloy components and high-temperature alloy forgings. It states that products are supplied to ASTM/ASME, DIN, BS, JIS and GOST standards and can be customised to a customer's drawings and technical requirements.
For verification, the website lists a spectrum analyzer, PMI testing, a metallographic analyzer, a universal tensile tester, an impact tester and notch projector, eddy current inspection, radiographic testing, and hydrostatic or non-destructive electric testing. The company also states that it is ISO 9001:2008 certified with more than 15 years of experience. Those capabilities map to checks 2, 4, 5, 6, 8 and 11 in the checklist above, and buyers should ask for the specific reports they need for each order.
For a spare that is needed quickly, a part machined from wrought super duplex bar or plate is often a practical alternative to a casting. It avoids foundry repair and casting NDE, and it matches the original wrought specification directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is a cast A995 grade 5A part the same as wrought S32750?
A: No. Grade 5A (UNS J93404) is the nearest cast equivalent of S32750, not an identical material. The chemistry limits, minimum strength and heat treatment differ, so the replacement must be approved against the original part's requirements.
Q: Are cast super duplex parts weaker than wrought ones?
A: On minimum values, yes. In the A995 table reviewed, grade 5A has a minimum yield strength of 515 MPa against 550 MPa for wrought F53, and grade 6A has 450 MPa against 550 MPa for wrought F55. Check that the design still works with the lower minimum.
Q: Does a cast part need heat treatment after a weld repair?
A: A890 supplementary requirement S33 calls for heat treatment after major weld repairs, defined as cavities deeper than 20% of wall thickness or 1 in (25 mm), or larger than about 10 in² (65 cm²). Minor repairs are not heat-treated unless the purchaser specifies it, so write your own rule into the order.
Q: Which tests should I request for a cast replacement impeller, valve body or fitting?
A: At minimum: heat chemistry with nitrogen and PREN, tensile and hardness results, Charpy impact at an agreed temperature, ferrite by ASTM E562 point count, an ASTM A923 intermetallic screen, radiographic or ultrasonic testing plus penetrant or magnetic particle testing, and the full weld-repair record.
Q: Can I use the same ferrite range as for the wrought part?
A: Usually the same working range is a sensible starting point, because both are duplex structures. Wrought datasheets commonly quote 40–60%, and one pump specification sets 35–65%. Whatever range you choose, state it in the order and require point counting by ASTM E562 on the casting.
Q: Can cast 5A be used in sour service?
A: A published pump specification treats A890 grade 5A as acceptable under both NACE MR0103 and MR0175, but approvals depend on the edition, service limits and hardness. Ask for hardness results on the part and confirm against the current standard.
Q: Should I always choose wrought material for a replacement part?
A: No. Castings suit complex shapes and longer production runs, and can lower cost on larger components. Wrought bar, plate or forgings are often safer for one-off or critical parts because they are much less likely to hide internal defects.

