In early 2024, a Middle Eastern gas processing plant faced a 14-week delay and $2.1 million in cost overruns - not because of a design flaw, not because of a contractor error, but because the Material Requisition for 316L stainless steel pipe specified the wrong ASTM edition. The mill delivered pipe to ASTM A312-19. The project required ASTM A312-22. The difference? A single updated clause on hydrostatic test acceptance criteria. The entire lot was rejected at site, and 84 tonnes of perfectly good pipe sat in a warehouse while procurement scrambled for a replacement.

Material Requisitions are the single most underrated document in EPC procurement. Engineers treat them as paperwork - a checkbox between detailed design and purchase order. But procurement professionals know: the MR is the contract before the contract. Every ambiguity in an MR becomes a cost item. Every missing clause becomes a variation order. Every conflicting standard becomes a delivery delay.
This guide is written for EPC engineers, procurement specialists, and project managers who want to write Material Requisitions that leave zero room for interpretation. It covers stainless steels (austenitic, duplex, ferritic) and nickel alloys (Inconel, Hastelloy, Monel) across oil & gas, chemical processing, power generation, and LNG projects. The advice here comes from 15+ years of manufacturing and supplying these materials to EPC projects worldwide.
What Is a Material Requisition in EPC?
A Material Requisition is a formal internal document that tells procurement exactly what to buy. It bridges engineering design and commercial purchasing.
The MR Is NOT a Purchase Order
|
Aspect |
Material Requisition (MR) |
Purchase Order (PO) |
|
Issued by |
Engineering / Project Team |
Procurement / Supply Chain |
|
Audience |
Internal procurement team |
External supplier / vendor |
|
Content type |
Technical requirements only |
Technical + Commercial + Legal |
|
When created |
After detailed engineering |
After competitive bidding / negotiation |
|
Legal binding |
No (internal document) |
Yes (contract between buyer and seller) |
|
Typical length |
3–15 pages (technical) |
20–60 pages (full package) |
Where the MR Fits in the EPC Workflow
- Process Design → P&ID / PFD finalised
- Material Selection Report → Grade chosen, corrosion study approved
- MR Issued → Engineering specifies everything procurement needs
- Inquiry / RFQ → MR sent to qualified vendors
- Technical Bid Evaluation → Vendor offers compared against MR
- Purchase Order → MR incorporated by reference into PO
- Mill Production → Vendor manufactures to PO + MR
- Inspection / Testing → Third-party verifies against MR
- Delivery & Receiving → Goods checked against MR requirements
When the MR is sloppy, the entire chain downstream suffers. Procurement sends unclear specifications to vendors. Vendors interpret ambiguity in the cheapest possible way. Inspection has no firm pass/fail criteria. And the site receives material nobody wants to sign off.
What Does a Bad MR Actually Cost?
The costs cascade through every phase of the project. A poorly written MR is not just a paperwork error - it is a financial liability.
|
Cost Category |
Typical Impact |
Real Example |
|
Re-bidding / re-tendering |
4–8 weeks delay |
Offshore platform project re-tendered 316L pipe when MR failed to specify sour service requirements |
|
Material rejection at receiving |
$50K–$500K per lot |
84t of 316L pipe rejected at Middle Eastern gas plant - $2.1M total impact |
|
Expediting / air freight |
3–10× standard freight |
2t of Inconel 625 fittings air-freighted at $18K because MR did not flag long-lead items early |
|
Construction idle time |
$10K–$100K per day |
Pipe rack erection stopped 6 days waiting for correct flange class after MR ambiguity |
|
Concession / deviation requests |
Engineering hours + risk acceptance |
3 weeks of engineering review to accept non-compliant U-bend radius in duplex exchanger tubes |
|
Liquidated damages on project delay |
Contract-dependent (often 5–10% of contract value) |
Delayed LNG module handover triggered LD clause - root cause traced to MR revision cycle |
A bad MR costs the project 3–15× more than the engineering hours saved by writing it quickly. The single most expensive decision you can make in EPC procurement is rushing the Material Requisition.
The 8 Core Elements of a Bulletproof MR
Every Material Requisition for stainless steel or nickel alloy must cover these eight elements. Skip one, and you create an ambiguity that someone downstream will exploit - or misunderstand.
|
# |
Element |
What It Answers |
Consequence If Missing |
|
1 |
Grade & Standard |
Exactly which alloy, to which standard? |
Vendor supplies nearest equivalent - may fail in service |
|
2 |
Mechanical Properties |
Strength, hardness, toughness? |
Material passes chemical check but fails structural design |
|
3 |
Corrosion Requirements |
What environment will the material face? |
316L supplied when duplex was needed for chloride service |
|
4 |
Dimensions & Tolerances |
What size, wall thickness, straightness? |
Pipe fits on drawing but not on site (wall tolerance stack-up) |
|
5 |
NDE & Testing |
What tests, to what standard, at what frequency? |
Vendor does minimum testing; defect found at hydrotest, not before |
|
6 |
Certification |
EN 10204 2.2, 3.1, or 3.2? |
Uncertified material accepted; no traceability when failure occurs |
|
7 |
Supplementary Requirements |
Any special conditions (sour service, cryogenic, PMI)? |
Standard material supplied for non-standard service |
|
8 |
Delivery & Marking |
How should material be marked, packed, delivered? |
Mixed heats on site; PMI cannot verify which is which |
How to Specify Stainless Steel Grades Without Creating Confusion
The most common MR error in stainless steel is ambiguous grade specification. Engineers often write "316L stainless steel" thinking it is sufficient. It is not.
Always specify three identifiers for every grade: (1) UNS number, (2) Werkstoffnummer (W.Nr.), and (3) the ASTM/EN standard reference. This eliminates any possibility of a vendor substituting a "close enough" grade.
Correct Example:
UNS S31603 / W.Nr. 1.4404 / ASTM A312 TP316L - Seamless Stainless Steel Pipe
Incorrect Example:
"316L pipe" or "SS316L pipe" (ambiguous - welded or seamless? ASTM or EN? Dual-certified?)
Common Stainless Steel & Nickel Alloy Grades in EPC Projects
|
Common Name |
UNS |
W.Nr. |
Key ASTM Spec |
Typical EPC Application |
PREN Range |
|
304/304L |
S30400/S30403 |
1.4301/1.4307 |
A312 TP304/304L |
Utility piping, structures, non-corrosive service |
18–20 |
|
316/316L |
S31600/S31603 |
1.4401/1.4404 |
A312 TP316/316L |
Chemical, marine, food processing |
24–26 |
|
321/321H |
S32100/S32109 |
1.4541/1.4878 |
A312 TP321/321H |
High-temperature (up to 900°C), stabilised |
18–20 |
|
310S |
S31008 |
1.4845 |
A312 TP310S |
Furnace parts, heat treatment equipment |
22–24 |
|
317L |
S31703 |
1.4438 |
A312 TP317L |
High-corrosion chemical service, FGD |
29–32 |
|
2205 Duplex |
S32205/S31803 |
1.4462 |
A790 S32205 |
Offshore, seawater, H₂S service |
34–36 |
|
2507 Super Duplex |
S32750 |
1.4410 |
A790 S32750 |
Deep water, high-chloride, sour service |
41–43 |
|
904L |
N08904 |
1.4539 |
A312/A269 (not in A312) |
Phosphoric acid, sulfuric acid |
34–36 |
|
6% Mo (254SMO) |
S31254 |
1.4547 |
A312 S31254 |
Seawater cooling, bleach plants |
43–45 |
|
Inconel 625 |
N06625 |
2.4856 |
B444/B704/B705 |
Sour gas, seawater, HPHT |
48–52 |
|
Inconel 600 |
N06600 |
2.4816 |
B167/B168 |
High-temperature oxidation, nuclear |
N/A (Ni-Cr-Fe) |
|
Inconel 825 |
N08825 |
2.4858 |
B423/B424 |
Sulfuric acid, phosphoric acid, seawater |
31–34 |
|
Hastelloy C-276 |
N10276 |
2.4819 |
B622/B619 |
Aggressive acids, FGD, chemical |
64–68 |
|
Hastelloy C-22 |
N06022 |
2.4602 |
B622/B619 |
Oxidising + reducing mixed acid |
65–70 |
|
Monel 400 |
N04400 |
2.4360 |
B165/B127 |
Seawater, HF acid, marine |
N/A (Ni-Cu) |
|
Alloy 20 |
N08020 |
2.4660 |
B729/B464 |
Sulfuric acid (≤80°C) |
28–30 |
Many mills offer dual-certified 304/304L or 316/316L. The carbon content of the "L" grade (max 0.030% for 304L, max 0.035% for 316L per ASTM A240) controls weld decay resistance. If your project requires post-weld corrosion resistance, specify the "L" grade explicitly. Do not rely on dual certification unless you have confirmed the carbon content meets the "L" limit.
Mechanical Properties in MR
Over-specifying mechanical properties is almost as expensive as under-specifying them. Every additional hardness test, every extra tensile coupon, every supplementary Charpy requirement adds cost and lead time - sometimes doubling the mill's quoted price.

Which Tests Are Standard vs. Supplementary for Each Product Form
|
Property |
Pipe (A312) |
Tube (A269) |
Plate (A240) |
Bar (A276) |
Fittings (A403) |
|
Tensile (YS + UTS + Elongation) |
✅ Standard |
✅ Standard |
✅ Standard |
✅ Standard |
✅ Standard |
|
Hardness (HBW/HRB) |
⚠ Suppl. (S2) |
✅ Standard |
⚠ Suppl. |
✅ Standard |
⚠ Suppl. |
|
Flattening Test (Pipe) |
✅ Standard |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
Flare Test (Tube) |
- |
✅ Standard |
- |
- |
- |
|
Charpy Impact |
⚠ Suppl. (S3) |
⚠ Suppl. |
⚠ Suppl. (S5) |
⚠ Suppl. |
⚠ Suppl. |
|
Grain Size |
⚠ Suppl. (S1) |
✅ Standard |
⚠ Suppl. |
✅ Standard |
⚠ Suppl. |
|
IGC (Intergranular Corrosion) |
⚠ Suppl. (S4) |
⚠ Suppl. |
⚠ Suppl. |
⚠ Suppl. |
⚠ Suppl. |
|
Ferrite Content (Duplex) |
Specify % |
Specify % |
Specify % |
Specify % |
Specify % |
✅ = Standard per base specification; ⚠ = Must be explicitly invoked in MR/PO as supplementary requirement
The Redundant Hardness Test Trap
Many EPC specifications call for hardness testing on every heat of 316L pipe. ASTM A312 does not include hardness as a standard requirement. Adding it as supplementary requirement S2 increases cost by $50–$150 per test and adds 1–2 days to inspection. For standard 316L in non-corrosive service, this is wasteful. For duplex or nickel alloys in sour service, hardness testing is essential (NACE MR0175 requires HRC ≤ 28 for duplex, HRC ≤ 35 for solid-solution nickel alloys). Specify it only where a standard or service condition demands it.
Corrosion Resistance
Generic corrosion clauses - "material shall be suitable for corrosive service" - are legally meaningless and technically useless. They give the vendor no measurable criteria and give the owner no rejection rights. A bulletproof MR specifies corrosion requirements in quantifiable terms.
|
Level |
MR Wording Quality |
Example |
Outcome |
|
❌ Bad |
Vague / generic |
"Material shall resist corrosion" |
Vendor supplies cheapest compliant grade |
|
⚠ Adequate |
Names environment |
"Suitable for seawater service" |
Vendor may supply 316L - will pit |
|
✅ Good |
Quantifies conditions |
"Chloride ≤ 20,000 ppm, pH 5.5–7.0, 35–45°C" |
PREN ≥ 40 required → duplex minimum |
|
⭐ Best |
Specifies test method + acceptance |
"ASTM G48 Method A, 25°C, weight loss ≤ 4.0 g/m², no pitting at 20×" |
Unambiguous pass/fail = no dispute |
|
Service Condition |
Test Method |
Acceptance Criteria (Typical) |
Why It Matters |
|
Chloride pitting |
ASTM G48 Method A |
CPT ≥ service temp + 5°C |
Prevents pitting in seawater/brine |
|
Crevice corrosion |
ASTM G48 Method B/C |
CCT ≥ service temp |
Prevents under-deposit attack in heat exchangers |
|
Intergranular corrosion (IGC) |
ASTM A262 Practice E (Strauss) |
No cracks after 180° bend |
Verifies solution anneal was done correctly |
|
Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) |
NACE TM0177 / NACE TM0316 |
No cracking at 720 h at 90% AYS |
Critical for sour service (H₂S) |
|
Sulfuric acid dewpoint |
ASTM G31 immersion |
Corrosion rate ≤ 0.1 mm/yr |
FGD, acid plants, stacks |
|
Hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) |
NACE TM0284 |
CLR ≤ 15%, CTR ≤ 5%, CSR ≤ 2% |
Wet H₂S service |
|
Sulfide stress cracking (SSC) |
NACE TM0177 Method A |
No failure at specified stress level |
NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 compliance |
PREN: One Number That Prevents Most MR Errors
PREN (Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number) is the single most useful tool for specifying stainless steel corrosion resistance in an MR. It is calculated from chemical composition:
PREN = %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N (base formula, ASTM G48 context)
PREN = %Cr + 3.3 × (%Mo + 0.5 × %W) + 16 × %N (for alloys containing tungsten)
Instead of writing "material shall be suitable for chloride service," write: "Minimum PREN ≥ 40 per formula Cr + 3.3Mo + 16N." This immediately rules out 304L and 316L and points the procurement team toward duplex or 6% Mo grades. Precise, measurable, and unambiguous.
Dimensions and Tolerances: The #1 Source of Site Rejection
Dimensional errors are the single most common cause of material rejection at EPC project sites. The root cause is almost always the same: the MR specifies a nominal size without referencing the applicable dimensional standard.
Nominal vs. Actual: Why "2-inch Pipe" Is Not Enough
A "2-inch NPS Sch 40S pipe" can have an OD ranging from 60.0 mm to 60.5 mm depending on the manufacturing standard (ASME B36.19M allows OD tolerance of ±1.6 mm for NPS 2, but ASME B36.10M uses a different tolerance class). When the pipe meets the standard but the fabricator expected a different standard, the result is field modification - grinding, cutting, or rejection.
Critical Dimensional References for an MR
|
Product Form |
Dimensional Standard |
Key Tolerance to Check |
|
SS Pipe (welded) |
ASME B36.19M + ASTM A312 |
Wall thickness: −12.5% (A312) |
|
SS Pipe (seamless) |
ASME B36.19M + ASTM A312 |
Wall thickness: −12.5% (A312) |
|
SS Tube |
ASTM A269 / A213 |
OD ±0.005 in (small dia.), ±0.5% (large) |
|
SS Plate/Sheet |
ASTM A480 (flatness) |
Flatness: varies by thickness, check A480 Table |
|
SS Bar (round) |
ASTM A484/A484M |
Diameter: ±0.0076 mm up to ±0.30 mm |
|
Butt-Weld Fittings |
ASME B16.9 |
Centre-to-end dimension: ±1.6 mm up to ±6.4 mm |
|
Flanges |
ASME B16.5 / B16.47 |
Flange thickness: +3.2 / −0 mm |
|
Nickel Alloy Pipe |
ASTM B619 (welded) / B622 (seamless) |
Wall ±12.5% (B619), ±12.5% (B622) |
Wall Thickness: The Most Misunderstood Number
ASTM A312 allows a wall thickness tolerance of −12.5% for seamless pipe. On a nominal 7.11 mm wall (Sch 80S, NPS 6), this means the actual wall can be as low as 6.22 mm. If your MR specifically requires a minimum wall of 7.11 mm, you must write: "Minimum ordered wall thickness 7.90 mm (to guarantee minimum 7.11 mm after −12.5% mill tolerance per ASTM A312)." Failing to account for mill under-tolerance is the most expensive dimensional mistake in EPC procurement - and it shows up only at receiving inspection, when replacement means weeks of delay.
NDE and Testing: Be Specific or Pay for Nothing
Non-Destructive Examination clauses in MRs often default to boilerplate: "100% NDE per applicable standards." This is meaningless. Which NDE method? To which standard? At what acceptance level? By whom? If the MR does not answer these questions, the vendor will perform the minimum permitted by the base material specification - which, for many stainless steel products, is zero NDE.
NDE Specification Template
|
NDE Method |
Standard |
Extent (% of product) |
Acceptance Criteria |
Typical Application |
|
UT (Ultrasonic) |
ASTM A388 / EN 10228-3 |
100% for forgings |
No indications > reference level |
Heavy-wall forgings, valves |
|
RT (Radiography) |
ASME BPV Section V |
10%/25%/100% per spec |
ASME B31.3 Normal Service |
Butt welds on pipe spools |
|
PT (Liquid Penetrant) |
ASTM E165 / EN 10228-2 |
100% of accessible surfaces |
No relevant linear indications |
Fittings, castings, weld overlay |
|
ET (Eddy Current) |
ASTM E426 / EN 10228-4 |
100% of tubes |
Per tube spec (e.g., A213) |
Heat exchanger / condenser tubes |
|
PMI (Positive Material Identification) |
API RP 578 |
100% or statistical (5–10%) |
Grade confirmed per UNS |
All nickel alloys; critical SS service |
|
Hydrostatic Test |
ASTM A999 (pipe) |
100% of pipe |
No leakage; pressure per A999 Table |
All pressure-retaining pipe |
|
Visual Examination |
ASME BPV Section V Art.9 |
100% |
No surface defects > spec limit |
All products |
Certification and Documentation: EN 10204 and Beyond
The choice between EN 10204 Type 2.2, 3.1, and 3.2 is not just a paperwork decision. It determines who inspects the material, who signs the certificate, and who bears liability if the material fails in service.
|
Certificate Type |
Who Issues? |
Who Validates Test Results? |
Typical Use Case |
Relative Cost Impact |
|
EN 10204 2.1 |
Manufacturer (Declaration) |
Nobody - statement only |
Non-critical structural steel |
Base |
|
EN 10204 2.2 |
Manufacturer (Declaration) |
Manufacturer's QC (not independent) |
Low-criticality piping |
+0–5% |
|
EN 10204 3.1 |
Manufacturer |
Manufacturer's QC (independent of production) |
Pressure-retaining equipment; standard in EPC |
+5–15% |
|
EN 10204 3.2 |
Manufacturer + Third Party |
Third-party inspector (e.g., Lloyds, DNV, BV, TUV) |
Critical service; NACE MR0175; subsea; nuclear |
+15–30% |
What Must Appear on the MTR (Mill Test Report)
Always specify the minimum data fields required on the Material Test Report. If the MR is silent, you may receive an abbreviated certificate missing traceability data.
- Heat number (must match physical stamping/marking on material)
- Chemical composition (ladle analysis, all specified elements)
- Mechanical test results (YS, UTS, elongation, reduction of area)
- Hardness values (if supplementary requirement invoked)
- Corrosion test results (IGC, pitting, SCC - if specified)\
- NDE results with acceptance criteria used
- Heat treatment details (temperature, hold time, cooling method)
- Product dimensions inspected + standard referenced
- Name and signature of authorised QC representative
- EN 10204 type and date of issue
Supplementary Requirements for Nickel Alloys
Nickel alloys (Inconel, Hastelloy, Monel) bring supplementary requirements that are not covered by standard carbon-steel or stainless-steel MR templates. Missing these is a fast track to non-compliant material.
Nickel Alloy MR Checklist
|
Requirement |
Standard / Reference |
Why It Matters |
|
PMI on 100% of items |
API RP 578 |
Nickel alloys are visually identical to stainless; PMI prevents mix-up |
|
Full chemical (not just key elements) |
ASTM B880 (Ni alloy verification) |
Minor tramp elements (Pb, Bi, Se) can cause hot shortness |
|
Grain size control |
ASTM E112 (grain size ≤ 5 or finer for most) |
Grain size affects creep and corrosion resistance |
|
Solution anneal verification |
ASTM B880 |
Un-annealed Ni alloys have reduced corrosion resistance |
|
Intergranular attack test per ASTM G28 |
ASTM G28 Method A |
Verifies sensitisation resistance after welding simulation |
|
NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 |
NACE MR0175 Part 3 (Ni alloys) |
Mandatory for sour service - specifies hardness, HT condition |
|
Surface finish for corrosion service |
Per project spec (Ra ≤ 3.2 μm typical) |
Pickled + passivated finish required for corrosion service |
10 Most Common MR Mistakes - and How to Fix Each One
Every project has unique service conditions. Copying an MR from an onshore gas plant for an offshore platform MR guarantees errors - offshore requires different corrosion allowances, different NDE acceptance, and often different grade selection.
Mistake #2: Specifying "or Equivalent" Without Defining Equivalence
Giving the vendor freedom to propose an "equivalent" without defining equivalence criteria is a procurement disaster. If you allow alternatives, specify: (a) same UNS family, (b) PREN ≥ specified minimum, (c) mechanical properties ≥ specified minimum, (d) prior EPC project track record, (e) owner approval required before substitution.
Mistake #3: Conflicting Standards in the Same MR
Calling ASTM A312 for pipe dimensions and EN 10216-5 for tolerances creates an internal conflict. The vendor will choose the looser standard. Always designate a hierarchy: "In case of conflict, ASTM A312 shall govern over EN 10216-5."
Mistake #4: No Minimum Wall Thickness After Mill Tolerance
As covered in Section 7: failing to account for mill under-tolerance means the pipe arrives on site thinner than design requires. Always specify "ordered wall ≥ design wall + mill under-tolerance per applicable ASTM spec."
Mistake #5: Omitting the Applicable ASTM Edition Year
ASTM standards are revised every 1–5 years. A312-22 may add or change test requirements from A312-19. If your MR does not specify the edition, the vendor may supply to an older edition that your design basis assumed was superseded.
Mistake #6: No Weld End Preparation Specified
Pipe end finish matters enormously for site welding. If the MR is silent, pipe may arrive with plain ends when beveled ends were needed, or vice versa. Specify per ASME B16.25 with bevel angle, root face, and any special requirements.
Mistake #7: Requesting Tests That Conflict With Product Form
Requesting a flattening test on welded tube (weld seam perpendicular to flattening axis) per ASTM A312 is technically incorrect for tube products. Each product form has its own standard test methods - know which standard applies to which form.
Mistake #8: Ignoring Minimum Order Quantities (MOQ)
Specifying 2 metres of a custom-size 2507 super duplex pipe will either be rejected by every vendor or priced at 5–10× normal cost. Check mill MOQ before writing the MR and bundle small-quantity items where possible.
Mistake #9: No Delivery Condition Specified
"As-supplied" is not a delivery condition. Specify heat treatment state (solution annealed, annealed + pickled, bright annealed), surface finish (2B, #4, pickled only, polished), and protective coating (if any).
Mistake #10: Leaving QA/QC Requirements Open-Ended
Terms like "as per approved QAP" or "as agreed" in the MR are invitations for dispute. The QAP (Quality Assurance Plan) and ITP (Inspection and Test Plan) should be referenced by document number, revision, and date - not assumed.
EPC Case Studies: MRs That Made (or Broke) the Project
MR specified "ASTM A312 TP316L" without an edition year. Mill shipped A312-19 compliant pipe. Project design basis used A312-22, which introduced a tighter hydrostatic test acceptance criterion. The entire 84-tonne lot was rejected at receiving - 14 weeks delay, $2.1M impact.
Lesson: Always specify the ASTM edition year. Never write "latest edition" - write the specific year your design basis uses.
Case 2: The Seawater 316L Catastrophe (Southeast Asia Offshore Platform, 2022)
MR for heat exchanger tubes specified "316L stainless steel - suitable for seawater cooling service." The vendor supplied standard 316L. Within 8 months of commissioning, tubes showed severe pitting and crevice corrosion under deposits. Root cause: 316L PREN ≈ 24–26 is inadequate for warm seawater (PREN ≥ 40 required). Replacement with 6% Mo (S31254) cost $780K + 11 weeks downtime.
Lesson: Specify PREN minimum, never a generic "suitable for" statement in corrosive service.
Case 3: The MR That Saved 8 Weeks (North Sea FPSO, 2023)
An FPSO project MR for Inconel 625 cladded pipe specified: UNS N06625, W.Nr. 2.4856, ASTM B444 Gr.1 + B705 cladding, EN 10204 3.2 with DNV witness, PMI 100%, NACE MR0175 compliant, hardness ≤ HRC 35, ASTM G48 Method A CPT ≥ 50°C, ordered wall 14.3 mm minimum after 12.5% mill tolerance. The MR left no room for vendor interpretation. First lot passed inspection without a single NCR. Procurement lead estimated this MR saved 8 weeks compared to the average technical query (TQ) cycle for similar nickel-alloy packages.
Lesson: Precision in the MR eliminates the TQ cycle - the fastest way to save procurement time.
Frequently Asked Questions
EN 10204 3.1 is issued by the manufacturer's own QC department, which must be independent of the production department. The manufacturer tests and certifies its own material. EN 10204 3.2 adds a third-party inspector (e.g., Lloyds, DNV, BV, TUV) who witnesses the testing and co-signs the certificate. 3.2 is typically required for pressure equipment under PED 2014/68/EU Category III/IV, subsea equipment, and NACE MR0175 sour service. Cost difference is typically +15–30%.
Can I specify "316L or equivalent" in my MR?
You can, but you must define equivalence criteria. Without them, the vendor may propose a lower-cost grade (e.g., 304L) claiming it is equivalent for your conditions. Define: same UNS family (austenitic), PREN ≥ 24, mechanical properties ≥ ASTM A312 TP316L minimums, and owner approval required before substitution.
How do I specify stainless steel for sour service (H₂S)?
Follow NACE MR0175/ISO 15156. For austenitic SS: solution annealed, hardness ≤ HRC 22, free of cold work. For duplex SS: ferrite 35–65%, hardness ≤ HRC 28, ASTM G48 Method A CPT per project spec. For nickel alloys: hardness ≤ HRC 35 (solution annealed) or ≤ HRC 40 (age-hardened), specific UNS grades listed in MR0175 Table A.14–A.33. Always specify EN 10204 3.2 certification for sour service material.
What is the correct way to specify wall thickness in an MR for pipe?
Specify: (1) nominal wall per ASME B36.19M, (2) applicable tolerance per ASTM A312 (−12.5% for seamless), (3) minimum ordered wall = design wall / (1 − tolerance fraction). Example: for design minimum wall 7.11 mm under −12.5% tolerance: ordered wall = 7.11 / (1 − 0.125) = 8.13 mm minimum. Round up to next available schedule or specify "minimum ordered wall 8.13 mm."
How much NDE should my MR specify for stainless steel pipe?
It depends on service criticality. Non-critical utility pipe: hydrostatic test per A999 only (standard per A312). Process pipe: add 5–10% random RT on butt welds per B31.3. Lethal service / Category M: 100% RT. Nickel alloy pipe: always add 100% PMI. Sour service: add hardness testing per NACE MR0175. Specify acceptance criteria per ASME B31.3 or project-specific piping class.
Should I include delivery condition in the MR?
Absolutely. "As-supplied" is ambiguous. Specify: heat treatment state (solution annealed, annealed, quenched + tempered), surface finish (pickled, bright annealed, polished with Ra value if needed), and protective measures (end caps on pipes, interleaving paper between plates, seaworthy packing for ocean freight). Delivery condition specifications prevent arrival damage and site rework.
How do I handle conflicting standards in an MR?
Define a hierarchy of precedence. Example: "In case of conflict between referenced standards, the following order of precedence shall apply: (1) Project Specification [doc number], (2) This Material Requisition, (3) ASTM A312, (4) ASME B31.3, (5) EN 10204, (6) All other referenced standards." Without a hierarchy, the vendor will apply the most favourable interpretation - which is rarely what the project needs.
What supplementary requirements are essential for nickel alloy MRs?
The essential four: (1) PMI on 100% of items per API RP 578 - nickel alloys look identical to stainless steel and mixing is catastrophic, (2) Hardness per applicable product standard + NACE MR0175 if sour, (3) ASTM G28 Method A intergranular corrosion test to verify solution anneal quality, (4) EN 10204 3.2 with named third-party inspector. For Inconel 625 and Hastelloy C-276, also specify full chemical analysis (not just key elements) per ASTM B880.
Is there a standard MR template I can use?
While there is no universal industry-wide MR template, major EPC contractors and operators (Shell DEP, Total GS, Aramco SAES, BP GP) maintain internal MR templates. These are usually confidential but the structure is similar: (1) Scope, (2) Applicable Codes & Standards, (3) Material Requirements, (4) Mechanical Properties, (5) Corrosion Requirements, (6) Dimensions & Tolerances, (7) NDE & Testing, (8) Certification & Documentation, (9) Marking & Packing, (10) Attachments. Follow this 10-section structure and adapt it to your project's specific requirements.

