Ethylene cracking furnaces run some of the harshest metallurgical environments in the process industry: metal temperatures above 900°C, a carbon-rich atmosphere from cracked hydrocarbons and coke, and years of continuous thermal cycling between operation and decoking. Choosing the wrong alloy for a furnace component does not just shorten its life - it can trigger an unplanned shutdown that costs a cracker operator far more than the material itself ever would.

Incoloy 800 (UNS N08800) and 310S stainless steel (UNS S31008) are the two alloys most commonly compared for non-radiant furnace hardware - tube supports, hangers, baffles, and transfer-line exchanger parts. This guide answers the questions engineers actually ask when specifying between them, with a clear answer first and the technical reasoning behind it.
What Are Incoloy 800 and 310S Stainless Steel?
Incoloy 800 is a nickel-iron-chromium alloy built around a high nickel content for high-temperature corrosion resistance; 310S is a high-chromium austenitic stainless steel built for oxidation resistance at a lower material cost.
Incoloy 800 (and its higher-carbon variants 800H and 800HT) is a solid-solution-strengthened nickel-iron-chromium alloy developed specifically for sustained service in high-temperature, carbon- and sulfur-bearing atmospheres. Its nickel content - roughly double that of 310S - is the single design feature that defines how it behaves in a cracking furnace.
310S is the low-carbon variant of the 25-20 austenitic stainless steel family (Type 310). It relies on a high chromium content to form a stable, protective chromium-oxide scale and is widely used across the process industry wherever oxidation resistance at high temperature is needed without the cost of a nickel alloy.
What Is the Key Compositional Difference Between the Two Alloys?
Nickel content is the deciding difference: roughly 30–35% in Incoloy 800 versus roughly 19–22% in 310S - and that gap is what drives every performance and cost difference discussed in this article.
|
Element |
Incoloy 800 (UNS N08800) |
310S (UNS S31008) |
|
Nickel (Ni) |
30 – 35% |
19 – 22% |
|
Chromium (Cr) |
19 – 23% |
24 – 26% |
|
Iron (Fe) |
Balance (≥39.5%) |
Balance |
|
Carbon (C) |
≤ 0.10% (800H: 0.05–0.10%) |
≤ 0.08% |
|
Aluminum + Titanium |
0.30 – 1.20% combined |
Not intentionally added |
|
Base alloy family |
Nickel-iron-chromium alloy |
Austenitic stainless steel |
Table 1 - Nominal composition ranges per ASTM B408 / ASTM A240.
Two features stand out. First, Incoloy 800's higher nickel content lowers the solubility and diffusion rate of carbon in the metal matrix, which is the core reason it resists carburization better than 310S (discussed below). Second, 800's aluminum and titanium additions form fine intermetallic precipitates that support elevated-temperature strength - a benefit 310S does not have.
Which Alloy Withstands Higher Furnace Temperatures?
310S has a slightly higher rated ceiling for pure oxidation resistance (up to roughly 1150°C versus roughly 1100°C for Incoloy 800), but Incoloy 800 holds its mechanical strength and structural stability better across the temperature range a cracking furnace actually operates in.
Oxidation resistance and structural performance are two different properties, and this is where the two alloys are most often confused. 310S's high chromium content gives it excellent scale stability in clean, oxidizing atmospheres, which is why it is common in furnace linings, kiln hardware, and heat-treatment baskets. But a cracking furnace is not a clean oxidizing atmosphere - it combines high temperature with a reducing, carbon-rich boundary layer at the metal surface, plus sustained mechanical load from the tube's own weight and thermal cycling. Under those combined conditions, Incoloy 800 - particularly the 800H and 800HT grades - retains higher creep strength and dimensional stability, which is why it is the default choice for load-bearing furnace internals rather than 310S.
Which Alloy Resists Carburization Better?
Incoloy 800 resists carburization substantially better than 310S, because its higher nickel content reduces both the solubility and the inward diffusion rate of carbon at furnace temperatures - and carburization, not simple oxidation, is the dominant failure mode in cracking furnace hardware.

Carburization occurs when carbon from cracked hydrocarbons or adhered coke diffuses into the metal surface, forming brittle carbides along the grain boundaries. The carburized layer loses ductility and becomes prone to cracking under the thermal and mechanical stresses of normal furnace cycling. Because nickel has low carbon solubility, alloys richer in nickel resist this attack far better than iron-chromium grades. 310S, with only 19–22% nickel, is markedly more susceptible to carburization embrittlement than Incoloy 800 in the same coke-fouled service.
A documented failure analysis of an ethylene furnace outlet transfer line makes the point well: an Incoloy 800H tube - already one of the more carburization-resistant alloys available - cracked through its full wall thickness after five years of service once coke deposits raised the wall temperature and exposed the inner surface to a carbon-rich atmosphere long enough to embrittle it. The case illustrates two things at once: carburization is the mechanism furnace engineers must design against above all others, and even Incoloy 800H is not carburization-proof if coking and temperature control are not managed - which makes the far more carbon-susceptible 310S a poor choice for any furnace zone with sustained coke contact.
Which Alloy Has Better Long-Term Creep and Load-Bearing Strength?
Incoloy 800 - especially the 800H and 800HT grades - offers meaningfully higher creep-rupture strength for load-bearing components; 310S is adequate only for lightly loaded, non-critical furnace hardware.
Furnace tube supports, hangers, and transfer-line exchanger tubesheets carry sustained mechanical load at high temperature for years between turnarounds, so creep resistance (the slow, permanent deformation that occurs under load at high temperature) is as important as corrosion resistance. Incoloy 800H and 800HT use controlled carbon content and coarser grain size specifically to raise creep-rupture life. 310S was not designed with this objective and, while serviceable for lightly loaded brackets, baffles, and non-pressure internals, is not the preferred specification for any component that must carry structural load at peak furnace temperature over a multi-year run length.
Which Alloy Costs Less to Purchase?
310S costs less on a per-kilogram basis than Incoloy 800, because nickel is the most expensive alloying element in both, and 310S contains roughly 30–40% less of it.
Base metal pricing for both alloys moves with the London Metal Exchange nickel price, but the effect is proportional to nickel content. Because Incoloy 800 carries roughly 30–35% nickel versus roughly 19–22% for 310S, its mill price per kilogram is consistently higher, and that gap widens whenever nickel prices spike. For budget-constrained projects or components outside the furnace's most severe zones, this purchase-price gap is a legitimate reason to specify 310S.
Which Alloy Delivers a Lower Total Cost of Ownership?
There is no universal winner: Incoloy 800 typically wins on total cost of ownership in high-carburization, load-bearing zones because it avoids premature failure and unplanned downtime; 310S typically wins on total cost of ownership in lower-severity zones where its lower purchase price is not offset by any material benefit.
Purchase price is only one line in the cost equation. An ethylene cracker's production value runs into the millions of dollars per day, so an unplanned outage caused by a cracked tube hanger or a carburized transfer-line tubesheet can cost far more than the entire material budget for that component - many times over, once lost production, emergency repair labor, and expedited replacement parts are included.
In zones with sustained coke contact, high mechanical load, or limited turnaround access for inspection, Incoloy 800's higher purchase price is normally recovered several times over in extended service life and avoided downtime. In lower-temperature, low-load zones with easy access for routine inspection and replacement, that same premium buys little practical benefit, and 310S is the more rational specification.
Where Should Each Alloy Be Used in an Ethylene Cracking Furnace?
Reserve Incoloy 800/800H for carburization-prone, load-bearing components - radiant-section tube supports and hangers, and transfer-line exchanger tubes and tubesheets - and use 310S for lower-duty convection-section hardware, baffles, and non-pressure internals.

It is also worth being precise about what neither alloy is used for: the radiant coil itself - the primary cracking tube exposed directly to firebox temperatures above 1000°C - is normally centrifugally cast HK-40, HP, or a modified HP alloy, not Incoloy 800 or 310S. Incoloy 800 and 310S compete for the furnace's supporting hardware and heat-recovery equipment, not the radiant coil.
|
Furnace zone / component |
Typical governing factor |
Recommended alloy |
|
Radiant coil (primary cracking tube) |
Extreme temperature + creep |
Cast HK-40 / HP alloys (neither 800 nor 310S) |
|
Radiant-section tube hangers & supports |
Carburization + sustained load |
Incoloy 800 / 800H |
|
Transfer-line exchanger (TLE) tubes & tubesheets |
Carburization + rapid quench cycling |
Incoloy 800 / 800H |
|
Convection-section tube supports |
Moderate temperature, oxidation |
310S |
|
Furnace baffles & non-pressure internals |
Moderate temperature, low load |
310S |
|
Quench boiler internals |
Corrosion + thermal cycling |
Incoloy 800 |
Table 2 - Indicative alloy selection by furnace zone. Always confirm against the furnace licensor's mechanical design basis and the plant's actual metal-temperature and coking profile.
How Should You Choose Between Incoloy 800 and 310S for Your Project?
Base the decision on four questions - peak metal temperature, exposure to carbon/coke, mechanical load, and turnaround interval - rather than on purchase price alone.
- Peak metal temperature: does the component regularly exceed roughly 815°C, where creep and carburization both accelerate?
- Carbon exposure: is the surface in sustained contact with cracked hydrocarbons or coke deposits, or is it isolated from the process gas?
- Mechanical duty: does the component carry structural or pressure-boundary load, or is it a lightly loaded bracket, baffle, or shield?
- Turnaround interval and access: how long must the component last between inspections, and how disruptive is an unplanned replacement?
If the answer to the first three questions leans toward severe service, Incoloy 800 (or 800H/800HT for the most demanding, load-bearing positions) is the technically and economically sound choice despite its higher purchase price. If the component sits in a cooler, lower-load, easily inspected zone, 310S delivers adequate performance at a meaningfully lower cost.
Summary
|
Criterion |
Incoloy 800 (800H/800HT) |
310S Stainless Steel |
|
Nickel content |
30 – 35% |
19 – 22% |
|
Oxidation resistance ceiling |
Up to ~1100°C |
Up to ~1150°C |
|
Carburization resistance |
Better |
Weaker |
|
Creep / long-term load strength |
Better (esp. 800H/800HT) |
Adequate for light duty only |
|
Purchase price per kg |
Higher |
Lower |
|
Best-fit furnace role |
Carburizing, load-bearing hardware |
Lower-severity, non-pressure hardware |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Incoloy 800 the same as 310 stainless steel?
No. Incoloy 800 is a nickel-iron-chromium alloy with roughly 30–35% nickel, while 310S is an iron-chromium-nickel stainless steel with roughly 19–22% nickel. They are related in application but belong to different alloy families with different governing properties.
Can Incoloy 800 and 310S be welded to each other?
Yes, dissimilar-metal welds between Incoloy 800 and 310S are common in furnace fabrication and are typically made with a nickel-based filler metal to accommodate the difference in thermal expansion and composition between the two alloys.
What alloy is used for the radiant coil (cracking tube) itself?
Neither Incoloy 800 nor 310S. Radiant coils normally use centrifugally cast HK-40, HP, or modified HP alloys, which are designed for the extreme creep and temperature demands of the firebox. Incoloy 800 and 310S are specified for supporting hardware, not the coil itself.
Does 310S resist carburization at all?
310S offers some carburization resistance from its chromium content, but substantially less than Incoloy 800, because carburization resistance scales primarily with nickel content and 310S has roughly half the nickel of Incoloy 800.
Is Incoloy 800 always the better choice regardless of cost?
No. In lower-temperature, low-load, easily inspected furnace zones, 310S provides adequate performance at a lower purchase price, and specifying Incoloy 800 there adds cost without a corresponding service-life benefit.

